Retirement planning — Napa style

Lynn Weirick

Apr 2, 2024

Selecting the right retirement plan can be likened to the art of choosing a fine wine in the lush Napa Valley vineyards. Each variety, whether a Qualified or Non-Qualified Plan, presents its unique bouquet of advantages and disadvantages carefully crafted to meet the varied palates of employees and employers alike. Understanding these variances can help you make an informed choice which complements your financial goals as perfectly as a well-chosen wine complements a meal.

Qualified plans:

Imagine a collection of aged Napa reds each offering a distinct flavor profile yet adhering to the stringent qualities that define the region’s finest. Similarly, Qualified Plans are designed with certain regulatory standards and benefits, including:

Tax benefits: Contributions to qualified plans are generally tax-deductible for the employer and tax-deferred for the employee, allowing for potential growth of retirement savings over time aging gracefully until the time of retirement when they are savored.

Employer contributions: Employers can make contributions to qualified plans which can help attract and retain employees, as well as provide additional retirement savings for participants. These plans encourage broad employee participation.

Versatile blending options: Offering rollover opportunities, allowing one to combine the best from different barrels to achieve a perfect retirement blend.

Legal protection: Qualified plans are subject to certain legal protections under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), which sets standards for plan fiduciaries and provides safeguards for plan assets.

Yet, even the finest wines have their complexities. The potential for a taxable distribution is akin to a tannic aftertaste, possibly resulting in hefty taxation akin to a wine hangover upon retirement. However, the upfront tax relief and employer matches can be as rewarding as the first sip of a premium Cabernet Sauvignon.

Non-qualified plans:

Turning our gaze to the experimental vineyards that embrace flexibility and innovation, we find Non-Qualified Plans. These are akin to small-batch, avant-garde wines, offering plans with additional benefits beyond what is offered in qualified plans:

A palette of flexibility: They are more flexible than qualified plans in terms of eligibility criteria, contribution limits, and plan design. Employers can tailor them to specific executive needs like crafting unique wine blends. These can also be offered in a voluntary participant funded manner.

Retention and recruitment incentives: They can be used as a retention tool by providing benefits that are contingent on the employee remaining with the company for a certain period. Providing customizable supplemental rewards to key personnel, much like a limited-edition release helping to attract and retain top talent.

Tax deferral: Contributions to non-qualified plans are not tax-deductible. However, earnings on contributions grow tax-deferred until withdrawn, potentially allowing for greater accumulation of funds over time like allowing earnings to ferment and mature untaxed until retirement, enriching its financial bouquet.

No discrimination testing: Non-qualified plans are not subject to the nondiscrimination rules that apply to qualified plans, making them easier to implement and administer for select groups of employees.

Binding ties to the estate: The benefits of non-qualified plans can offer estate planning benefits. Participants can pass on the benefits to their heirs or beneficiaries reminiscent of a treasured vintage shared across generations. Benefit cost mitigation and payroll tax deductions are valuable components.

Customization: Employers have more freedom to customize the vesting schedules, distribution options, and other features of non-qualified plans to meet the needs of the company and its employees. If the vehicle for the plan is a life policy, the contributions, interest, and growth—if loaned out to participant—will never show up on a tax form.

Financial support/income before or after 65: A customized plan can allow distributions in times where the market falls, tax rates increase, or for financial needs like weddings, second homes, gifts, or dependent needs. If this plan is operating in a voluntary participant funded manner, distributions can start as early as 90 days.

Yet, this flexibility comes with its nuances involving a need for proper documentation and management. Contributions are not tax-deductible.

Contact Us

A Modern Approach to Executive Compensation & Retention

791 East 3rd Street Suite 200

Boston MA 02127